What to flag in IME records
Answer in brief: flag anything that changes an answer to a referral question or that the other side will ask you about: prior treatment of the same body part, a mechanism of injury that shifts between histories, gaps in care, imaging that later notes misquote, conflicting work status, records that are referenced but missing, and pages that belong to someone else. Log each flag with a page cite and a plan: a question, a test or a records request.
Limits: Not legal or billing advice. Rules and fees are quoted as read on 2026-11-19 from each state's official code or workers' compensation agency, cover only the states listed, and change every year; verify the current text there before you bill or sign, and ask counsel about your case.
Why a flag needs a page cite and a plan
A flag that says "prior back pain" is a memory aid. A flag that says "lumbar strain treated 2019-03-04 to 2019-05-20, Dr. A clinic, pp. 212 to 230; ask about symptoms between 2019 and the injury; compare 2019 and 2024 MRI levels" is evidence you can use in the report and defend at deposition. The page number lets you, a reviewer or opposing counsel go straight to the source. The plan turns the flag into something you do in the exam room.
Most flags fall into the same 12 groups across injury types. The order below follows the questions IME referrals usually ask: causation and apportionment first, then need for treatment, maximum medical improvement and work capacity, then the integrity of the record itself.
The 12 flag categories
| # | Flag | What it looks like in the file | Question it changes | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Prior treatment of the same body part | Visits, imaging, therapy or claims for the same region before the date of injury | Causation, apportionment | Ask about symptoms in the year before; compare old and new imaging level by level |
| 2 | Shifting mechanism of injury | First report says lifting; later histories say a fall, or add a second event | Causation | Quote each version with its page; take your own history before showing any record |
| 3 | Delayed first complaint | The body part first appears in the record weeks after the injury | Causation | Note the interval and any visits in between that do not mention it |
| 4 | Gap in care | No visits for months, then treatment resumes | Causation, MMI, intervening events | Record the dates and any stated reason (insurance, relocation, improvement); ask the examinee |
| 5 | Intervening event | A later car crash, fall, new job or sport injury after the claimed injury | Causation, apportionment | Request the records of that event if they are not in the file |
| 6 | Imaging misquoted | A clinic note describes the MRI differently from the radiology report | Diagnosis, need for treatment | Cite the radiology report as the source; review the images yourself if the answer depends on it |
| 7 | Conflicting exam findings | 2 providers in the same month record very different range of motion, strength or reflexes; nonorganic signs noted by 1 and not the other | Diagnosis, work capacity | List both with dates; plan the tests in your exam that would settle it |
| 8 | Treatment without documented change | Repeated injections or therapy blocks with no functional measure before or after | Need for treatment, MMI | Look for any outcome measure; note its absence plainly |
| 9 | Medication pattern | Escalating opioid doses, several prescribers, early refills noted | Need for treatment, work capacity | Build a short medication timeline with prescriber and page |
| 10 | Conflicting work status | Off-work notes overlapping with full-duty notes, or activity reports inconsistent with restrictions | Work capacity, temporary disability | Tabulate work status by date and source |
| 11 | Referenced but missing records | A discharge summary cites an operative note, or an MRI is ordered and never reported | Any | List each missing item and request it before the exam, or state its absence in the report |
| 12 | Record integrity | Another patient's pages, impossible dates, identical text copied forward across visits | Weight given to the record | Pull wrong-patient pages from your count; note copy-forward text without guessing at motive |
How to cite a flag in the report
Use the same citation form for every flag so a reader can check them fast. A form that works: source, date, page, then a short quote or paraphrase. For example: "Urgent care note, 2024-02-11, p. 14: 'lifting box at work, felt pull in low back.' Orthopedic consult, 2024-04-02, p. 88: 'fell from ladder at work.'" Quote when the exact words matter, as with a mechanism of injury. Paraphrase when they do not.
If the file is Bates-stamped, cite the Bates number rather than the PDF page, because PDF page numbers change when someone adds or removes a document. If it is not stamped, say which file and page numbering you used in the records-reviewed list.
Keep flags factual. "The 2024-04-02 history differs from the 2024-02-11 history" is a finding. "The examinee changed the story" is an opinion about honesty that you should reach only after the exam, if at all.
A flag log you can copy
Paste this into a spreadsheet or the notes pane of your PDF reader. 1 row per flag. The plan column is what you take into the exam room.
FLAG LOG: [claim number], date of injury [date], reviewed by [name]
# | Category (1-12) | Date in record | Source | Page / Bates | What the record says | Question affected | Plan
1 | 2 Mechanism | 2024-02-11 | Urgent care | p. 14 | "lifting box ... pull in back" | Causation | Take history before showing records
2 | 2 Mechanism | 2024-04-02 | Ortho consult | p. 88 | "fell from ladder" | Causation | Ask which happened, and when
3 | 11 Missing | 2024-05-19 | Discharge note | p. 301 | Cites L4-5 operative note | Need for surgery | Request op note from hospital
The 3 rows are synthetic, no real patient.
What not to flag
Flagging everything is as bad as flagging nothing, because the important items disappear. Skip routine findings that answer no referral question, normal labs unrelated to the claim, and administrative pages such as fax covers and billing ledgers, except where a ledger is the only proof that a visit happened. If you are unsure whether a finding matters, ask which referral question it would change. If none, leave it out of the log and keep it in your chronology.
For injury-specific items to look for, use the checklists by injury type. To see the log in use on a full synthetic file, read the worked example.