Worked example: reviewing a 640-page lumbar claim file
Answer in brief: this synthetic lumbar file (synthetic, no real patient) has 640 pages, of which 88 are duplicates and 4 belong to another patient, leaving 548 to review. At 50 pages an hour plus 2 MRI studies, the review takes about 11.3 hours and turns up 7 flags, including a 2019 lumbar MRI, 2 versions of the mechanism and a missing operative note. Washington would pay $187.96 for the reading, California $1,044.00 and Colorado $4,474.88.
Limits: Not legal or billing advice. Rules and fees are quoted as read on 2026-11-19 from each state's official code or workers' compensation agency, cover only the states listed, and change every year; verify the current text there before you bill or sign, and ask counsel about your case.
The referral
A 46-year-old warehouse worker reports a low back injury at work on 2024-02-10. The claim accepts a lumbar strain and disputes an L4-5 disc herniation, treated with a microdiscectomy in November 2024. The requester asks 4 questions: is the herniation caused by the work injury; was the surgery reasonable and necessary; has the worker reached maximum medical improvement; and what work can the worker do now. Every name, date and page in this example is invented.
Pass 2: the page inventory
Before reading a single note, count. The inventory changes every number that follows: hours, flags and the bill.
| Source | Dates covered | Pages | Exact duplicates | Other patient |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Employer report and claim forms | 2024-02 | 12 | 0 | 0 |
| Urgent care | 2024-02-11 to 2024-02-25 | 18 | 6 | 0 |
| Primary care | 2018-06 to 2024-09 | 96 | 14 | 4 |
| Chiropractic | 2019-03 to 2019-05 | 44 | 0 | 0 |
| Orthopedic spine | 2024-04 to 2025-01 | 132 | 30 | 0 |
| Imaging center | 2019-04, 2024-03, 2024-04 | 28 | 10 | 0 |
| Pain management | 2024-06 to 2024-12 | 86 | 12 | 0 |
| Physical therapy | 2024-03 to 2024-08 | 138 | 16 | 0 |
| Hospital surgical admission | 2024-11-13 to 2024-11-15 | 70 | 0 | 0 |
| Pharmacy printout | 2023-01 to 2025-01 | 16 | 0 | 0 |
| Total | 640 | 88 | 4 |
548 pages remain. The 4 other-patient pages go back to the requester with a note, and they stay out of the page count you certify.
Pass 3: the chronology, excerpt
The full chronology for this file runs to about 90 lines. These 10 carry the questions:
| Date | Source | Entry | Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019-03-04 | Chiropractic | Low back pain after moving furniture; treated 14 visits to 2019-05-20 | pp. 212 to 255 |
| 2019-04-18 | Imaging center | Lumbar MRI: mild L4-5 disc bulge, no nerve root contact | p. 402 |
| 2024-02-11 | Urgent care | "Lifting box at work, felt pull in low back." No leg symptoms. Off work 3 days | p. 14 |
| 2024-03-05 | Physical therapy | Evaluation: back pain only; straight leg raise negative both sides | p. 455 |
| 2024-04-02 | Orthopedic spine | "Fell from ladder at work." New left leg pain to the foot; weak left great toe extension | p. 88 |
| 2024-04-12 | Imaging center | Lumbar MRI: left L4-5 extrusion contacting the L5 root | p. 410 |
| 2024-06-15 | Physical therapy | Discharged for missed visits; next visit 2024-08-01 | p. 571 |
| 2024-08-20 | Pharmacy | Oxycodone filled from 2 prescribers in the same week | p. 634 |
| 2024-11-15 | Hospital | Discharge summary: "L4-5 left microdiscectomy on 2024-11-14, see operative note" | p. 301 |
| 2025-01-09 | Orthopedic spine | Leg pain resolved; back pain 3 of 10; light duty recommended | p. 140 |
Pass 5: the flags
| # | Flag | Pages | Plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Prior lumbar treatment and a 2019 MRI at the same level | 212 to 255, 402 | Ask about back symptoms from 2019 to 2024; compare the 2019 and 2024 images, not only the reports |
| 2 | Mechanism changes from lifting (urgent care) to a ladder fall (orthopedics) | 14, 88 | Take a history before showing any record; ask whether there were 2 events |
| 3 | First leg symptoms 7 weeks after the injury; PT on 2024-03-05 records a negative straight leg raise | 455, 88 | Ask when the leg pain began and what happened just before |
| 4 | Gap in therapy from 2024-06-15 to 2024-08-01 | 571 | Ask the reason; look for any event in the gap |
| 5 | Overlapping opioid prescriptions from 2 prescribers | 634 | Build a medication timeline; note without inferring motive |
| 6 | Operative note cited in the discharge summary but not in the file | 301 | Request it before the exam; the surgery question depends on it |
| 7 | 4 pages for another patient in the primary care records | 61 to 64 | Remove from the count; tell the requester |
Pass 6 and the bill
The close-out produces a records-reviewed list of 10 sources with page ranges, a certified count of 548 pages, a request for the operative note, and an exam plan built from flags 1 to 4. Time: 548 pages at 50 pages an hour is 10.96 hours, plus 2 MRI studies read at 10 minutes each, about 11.3 hours. What that reading is worth:
| Schedule | What counts | Arithmetic | Paid for reading |
|---|---|---|---|
| Washington 1129M | 548 unique pages, 400 included | 148 x $1.27 | $187.96 |
| California ML-PRR | 548 pages reviewed, 200 included | 348 x $3.00 | $1,044.00 |
| Colorado | 11.3 hours, 46 units of 15 minutes | 46 x $97.28 | $4,474.88 |
| Texas designated doctor | Bundled | none | $0 beyond the exam fee |
Run the same numbers with your own pace in the estimator. The rules behind each line are on the state rules page.
What this example teaches
- Count first. 92 of 640 pages (14%) were duplicates or the wrong patient. Reading them would have cost about 1.8 hours and earned nothing in Washington.
- The questions live in a handful of pages. 10 chronology lines carry all 4 referral questions. The other 538 pages confirm the picture or add nothing.
- The missing record is the most important flag. Without the operative note, the surgery question cannot be answered from the file. Ask for it before the exam, not in an addendum.
- Old records matter most for causation. The 2019 chiropractic notes and MRI sit 5 years before the injury, in a source most requesters would not think to send. Here they were sent; often they are not, which makes "prior records requested" a standard line in the exam plan.